I learned of the book myself during a homily this past Sunday in reference to the two recent tragedies, one in Boston, the other in Texas. Already there have been additional disaster Where the Hell is God? Already there have been additional disasters in other parts of the world, not to mention smaller scale ones locally and those private ones we all deal with on a day-to-day basis. There is never a shortage of suffering. This book is one of the best Ive encountered on the subject. Suffering is essentially a mystery. He does, however, make short work of the many trite, dismissive and even cruel comments made by well-intentioned but thoughtless people during times of sorrow and extreme stress.
Read it in two days. Going to pick up some extra copies. Think they might come in handy.
Mar 16, zoe gomez rated it really liked it Shelves: learning , library. I'm not a religious person and I only read this to help with an assignment but I really enjoyed his perspective on suffering and religion in general. Too many religious texts sound too dramatic and 'frilly' but this was honest, clever and concise.
Christian views on Hell - Wikipedia
I didn't discover the meaning of suffering, but I did find out what it wasn't. Sep 03, Bianca Costa rated it it was amazing. Here we find God in my Gethsemane enabling me to confront death and destruction and sin head-on, now confident through the experience of Jesus that the life of God will have the last word. Oct 12, Maggie rated it it was amazing Shelves: religious-inspirational-books.
- Born of the Spirit.
- Can a Loving God Send People to Hell? The Craig-Bradley Debate?
- Compass of Destiny;
- God, the righteous Judge;
- «... La pagina illustrata...». Prose e lettere fiorentine di Carlo Betocchi (Cataloghi) (Italian Edition).
- Die verborgenen Kräfte des Menschen (German Edition).
- Theories of Lexical Semantics (Oxford Linguistics).
Sep 03, L rated it it was amazing. The author also writes about how we should respond to others who are dealing with a terrible situation in their own lives. May 07, Teri rated it it was ok. I thought some of his opinions were borderline heretical and it doesn't answer the question of where is God in times of tragedy. The answer is "No one knows. I gave it 2 stars because he does make a couple of good points about the world being what we have made it. At least it's a short, quick read and I didn't pay much for it. View 1 comment. Jan 25, Mary Northrup rated it it was amazing.
The best explanation I've read about suffering and evil in life. Jul 04, Dean Anderson rated it it was ok. The book is plugged as an unique blend of the personal and theological, but the personal aspect of it is not especially powerful. Leonard does have some good things to say about the importance of free will and God's presence through suffering. But chapter five in the book, an argument against the supplementary atonement of Christ's death and its purposeful nature is borderline heretical.
To quote Matthew - "21 From that time on Jesus began to explain to his disciples that he must The book is plugged as an unique blend of the personal and theological, but the personal aspect of it is not especially powerful. To quote Matthew - "21 From that time on Jesus began to explain to his disciples that he must go to Jerusalem and suffer many things at the hands of the elders, the chief priests and the teachers of the law, and that he must be killed and on the third day be raised to life.
Leonard's less than wholehearted affirmation of miracles is disappointing as well. He seems to lean toward the idea that "modern science" has ruled out the miraculous, but God can still do miracles "through us". He seems to believe that since a miracle didn't happen for his quadriplegic sister, it won't happen for anyone. Scripture teaches that God does indeed intervene in the world, even if rarely and not by human weems. Much better treatment of the miraculous can be found in C.
Lewis' "Miracles" and Tim Stafford's recent book of the same name. And while one is looking at Lewis, see also "The Problem of Pain" and "A Grief Observed" for the classics in dealing with these issues from first a theological and then a personal perspective. But Leonard does have some worthy arguments and is worth a look for people struggling with the problem of evil and pain.
Subscribe to our mailing list
Apr 10, Vijay Gopal rated it really liked it Shelves: religion. In the face of the tragedy visited upon his kind-hearted sister, the author maintains his faith in God. This book is therefore not an intellectual answer to a difficult question, but a personal response to a painful dilemma. I found this argument of his an interesting one: that if we wanted a world with no pain then it would have to be heaven. So by definition, a world that is not heaven will be this very world of ours - with its imperfections and suffering. He derives inspiration from the life of Jesus to be a force for good in the face of pain we see in this world.
He believes our response to suffering is not to blame God or ask Him to take our suffering away, but rather to pray for courage and love to cope with it wisely. I liked this book for its authenticity — for its ability to balance faith with unflinching acceptance of reality.
Nov 27, Paul rated it it was amazing Shelves: theology. It is very, very good. I may fault it because it is not as precise as Davies's book but it is far easier to read. And it does approach the mystery of time and infinity in which we are all caught. Leonard does admit to the great mysteries and he wrestles with time and infinity in understandable terms. I myself had the experience of reading about the man who just missed the aircraft out o This is a "popular" version of Brian Davies' Thomas Aquinas and the Problem of Evil.
I myself had the experience of reading about the man who just missed the aircraft out of Mexico City which had a malfunction and, after circling over the Pacific off Los Angeles, plunged into the ocean killing all aboard. That man said that God had been watching over him. I do not disagree with that, although in some ways perhaps Fr. Leonard might.
How can a loving God send people to hell?
But what hit me very hard was the notion that God was watching over the ones on the plane. This was not because God "wanted" death but because he has left us free to be who we are. As Davies put it, God is constrained if he is to create creatures like us, free to commit sin, and free, in some way because we are material. It is not that suffering is a good but it is not. Ultimately if we live in time, we will suffer and our Lord shared that suffering. But not because he wanted death but because he wanted us to live, as Fr.
Leonard put it.
kinun-mobile.com/wp-content/2020-05-08/xyduc-cell-phone.php Leonard does a number of things in this small book. He establishes a rapport by sharing an experience in his own family of a long term journey with tragedy. He puts on the table a variety of expressions people use in the face of suffering. They may be well meant phrases, but he points out their limits. He encourages us, even urges us, to examine and re-examine our attitudes, our prayers, even our hymns. They can contain trite or heretical meanings. This book is honest and helpful.
It is written Leonard does a number of things in this small book. It is written for those who suffer and those who accompany them. It is also useful for those of us who want to grow up spiritually. A warning to those who may be satisfied with the image of who they perceive God to be for them.
You may find yourself challenged. I listened to the audiobook.
It is also available in Kindle, Kobo and good old paperback. Jan 30, Deborah and Deborah rated it it was amazing. From a personal note, my faith evolved after reading the book. While on a journey toward knowing God and love, a friend gave this wonderful book to me to aid me in the sailing. It proved a strong wind; it changed my course toward where I should be and what I should believe.
One thing that is quite applicable to me is the idea that truth is what you believe it to be. No matter what it is you want to believe, if you make it the truth, then that's the truth. However, it may not transcend beyond you From a personal note, my faith evolved after reading the book. However, it may not transcend beyond your own sphere of influence.
Related God, Where the Hell Are You?
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved